Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Edward Carson, 9 June 1916
Private 9th June, 1916. My dear Carson, The contents of this day's Nationalists papers look
as if we might have a repudiation of Redmond's provisional consent
to the six Counties plan before Monday, which would save us from
a considerable difficulty. If this does not occur it will be obviously right
tactics for us to authorise you to enter upon negotiations on
the six counties basis. I hope, however, that you will arrange to have a
resolution proposed which will make it clear that we only do this
under great stress on account of the war, & that we are not
bound by what we do on Monday under any other circumstance that
may arise. The resolution should contain some plausible excuse
(1) for breaking or stretching the terms of the Covenant (2)
(which I think quite as important) for giving even a n co i mplied assent
to the setting up of Home Rule for any part of Ireland at present,
involving as it does most serious danger to the Realm and with which
even implicit consent appears to me to amount to an act of treason
which requires a very valid excuse. I feel that it is as big
a breach of my oath of allegiance as the abtaining abandoning of the three
counties is of the covenant! I attended the Unionists Alliance meeting yesterday
Some of them had been seeing Lloyd George and had received certain
offers from him, after considering which they passed the 2 resolution in to-day's papers. I got them to tone one part of
it which I think thought very unwise down a little, but did not try to
prevent them issuing it. Not knowing, however what sort of
resolution I might find myself obliged to vote for on Monday
I left the room before the resolution was put and they have consider-
ately omitted my name from the list of those present. Yours very truly, Hugh Montgomery. Monday's resolution shd also contain a strong instruction
to you to get the best safequards you can for unionists
outside the 6 counties — not to ginger you up -
but to show Southern Unionists that we are not
forgetting them.
This letter was written by Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery (1844-1924). Montgomery was a landowner and politician. Originally a liberal and a strong supporter of Gladstone, Montgomery was also a firm unionist, but by 1916 he believed that Ulster unionists had no choice but to accept Lloyd George's proposal for a six-county Northern Ireland. The letter was addressed to Edward Carson (1854-1935). Carson was a lawyer and a politician. In 1916 he was at the peak of his parliamentary influence. It was in 1916 that he accepted the first lordship of the admiralty. In addition to this, Carson was also a leading unionist figure in Irish politics. He sanctioned the formation of the paramilitary Ulster Volunteer Force in January 1913; and he helped to found the Ulster provisional government of September 1913. This letter concerns nationalist and unionist politics. Montgomery writes about a nationalist repudiation of Redmond's provisional consent to the six counties plan. If, however, this does not occur, Montgomery authorizes Carson to enter into negotiations on a six county basis. Montgomery states that any resolution resulting from these negotiations are a result of the stresses of war and cannot be held as binding. Montgomery goes on to express his opinion that Home Rule is an act of treason and a breach of his oath of allegiance.
- Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery
- Edward Carson
- 1916-06-09
- Politics
How to cite
Letters 1916, published by the Austrian Centre for Digital Humanities, Vienna, 2026 (https://letters1916static.github.io/letters1916-static/item__2232.html)
- Mentioned in
-
- Letter from David Lloyd George to Edward Carson, 29 May 1916
- Letter from Sir Dawson Bates to Edward Carson, 2 December 1915
- Letter from William Robert Young to Edward Carson, 9 July 1916
- Letter from Alexander McDowell to Edward Carson, 20 July 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenerg Montgomery to Edward Carson, 31 May 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Edward Carson, 9 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Edward Carson, 9 June 1916
- Letter from Frederick Hugh Crawford to Edward Carson, 8 March 1916
- Letter from Edward Carson to Thomas McGregor Greer, 12 July 1916
- Letter from Sir Edward Carson to Sir Robert Ponsonby Staples, 10 December 1915
- Letter to Edward Carson, 19 November 1915
- Letter from William R. Young to Edward Carson, 2 November 1915
- Letter from J.M. Wilson to Edward Carson, 3 November 1915
- Letter from Turner Oliver Read to Edward Carson, 12 November 1915
- Letter from William R. Young to Edward Carson, 12 November 1915
- Letter from Harold Tennant to Edward Carson, 17 November 1915
- Letter from Henry Mulholland to Pembroke Wicks, circa November 1915
- Letter from Wilfrid Spender to Edward Carson, 25 November 1915
- Letter Wilfrid Spender to Edward Carson, 3 December 1915
- Letter to Edward Carson, 4 December 1915
- Letter from Robert Thompson to Edward Carson, 18 December 1915
- Letter from W.T. Bailey to Edward Carson, 22 December 1915
- Letter from General Nevil Macready to Edward Carson, 1 May 1916
- Letter to Edward Carson, 2 May 1916
- Letter from Horace Plunkett to Edward Carson, 4 May 1916
- Postcard to Edward Carson, 4 May 1916
- Letter from D.P. Barton to Edward Carson, 5 May 1916
- Letter from Edward Carson to Herbert Asquith, 9 May 1916
- Letter from Herbert Asquith to Edward Carson, 10 May 1916
- Copy of a letter from John Crozier to Edward Carson, 9 May 1916
- Letter from J.M. Wilson to Edward Carson, 11 May 1916
- Letter to Edward Carson, 15 May 1916
- Letter from David Lloyd George to Edward Carson, 3 June 1916
- Letter from G.L. Moore to Edward Carson, 6 June 1916
- Letter from sir William Robert Robertson to Edward Carson, 7 June 1916
- Letter from Nevil Macready to Edward Carson, 8 June 1916
- Letter from Arthur Warren Samuels to Edward Carson, 14 June 1916
- Letter from Frederick Stringer Wrench to Edward Carson, 15 June 1916
- Letter from Somerset Francis Saunderson to Edward Carson, 15 June 1916
- Letter to Edward Carson, 17 June 1916
- Letter from Somerset Francis Saunderson to Edward Carson, 17 June 1916
- Letter from Charles Clements to Edward Carson, 21 June 1916
- Letter from Ronald McNeill to Edward Carson, 22 June 1916
- Letter from John Crozier to Edward Carson, 26 June 1916
- Letter from Charles F. Down to Edward Carson, 28 June 1916
- Letter from Charles Clements to Edward Carson, 29 June 1916
- Letter from Archibald Salvidge to Edward Carson, 30 June 1916
- Letter from Charles Clements to Edward Carson, 1 July 1916
- Letter from Charles Clements to Edward Carson, 3 July 1916
- Letter to Edward Carson, 5 July 1916
- Letter from Horace Plunkett to Edward Carson, 5 July 1916
- Letter from Charles F Down to Edward Carson, 8 June 1916
- Letter from Herbert Samuel to Edward Carson, 13 July 1916
- Letter from William Martin to Edward Carson, 13 July 1916
- Letter from Travers R. Blackley to Edward Carson, 11 July 1916
- Letter from Travers R. Blackley to Edward Carson, 13 July 1916
- Letter from Pembroke Wicks to Edward Carson, 14 July 1916
- Letter from Somerset Francis Saunderson to Edward Carson, 15 July 1916
- Letter from Edward Carson to William Martin, 17 July 1916
- Letter from Herbert Samuel to Edward Carson, 21 July 1916
- Letter to Edward Carson, 21 July 1916
- Letter from John Strachey to Edward Carson, 27 July 1916
- Letter from Alexander McDowell to Edward Carson, 5 October 1916
- Letter to Edward Carson, 7 October 1916
- Letter from Sharman D Neill to Edward Carson, 7 October 1916
- Letter from John Strachey to Edward Carson, 7 October 1916
- Letter from Rosalind Hamilton to Edward Carson, 10 October 1916
- Letter to Edward Carson, 14 October 1916
- Letter from David Lloyd George to Edward Carson, 14 October 1916
- Letter from J. Beatty to Edward Carson, 16 October 1916
- Letter from Edward Carson to Richard Dawson Bates, 21 April 1919
- Mentioned in
-
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to William Coote, 25 March 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenerg Montgomery to Edward Carson, 31 May 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Edward Carson, 9 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Willis, 10 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Edward Carson, 9 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to 'Canon', 10 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to W. G. Vance, 13 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Vernon, 15 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Willis, 15 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Hamilton, 10 June 1916
- Letter to Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery from Walter Long, 2 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to George Francis Stewart, 17 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to James Stronge, 3 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to John Edward Fowler Sclater, 3 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to James Stronge, 9 June 1916.
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Mr Glasgow, 18 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to George Francis Stewart, 18 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Hugo, 27 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Maurice Headlam, 19 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery, 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Charles Hubert Montgomery, 30 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to William Hovenden Ffolliott, 2 August 1916
- Letter from Charles Hubert Montgomery to Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery, 29 May 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to John Ross, 27 May 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to William Coote, 27 May 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to William Coote, 22 May 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Waldron, 26 June 1916
- Letter to Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery from Sir John Ross, 2 June 1916.
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Sir Richard Dawson Bates, 23 June 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to William Coote, 9 Spetember 1916
- Letter from Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery to Walter Long, 31 May 1916
- Letter from M. E. Sinclair to Hugh de Fellenberg Montgomery, 18 September 1916