Letter from Bishop Edward Thomas O'Dwyer to General John Grenfell Maxwell, 17 May 1916
ceipt of your letter of 12th. which
has been forwarded to me here. I have read very carefully
your allegations against MrThomas,
Wall, and Mr.. Michael Hayes, I
do not see in them any justification
for disciplining action in any part
against them. They are both excellent
priests, who hold rather
but I do not know that they have
violated any law, civil or ec-
-clesiastical. In your letter of 6th inst.
I'm appealed to me to keep free &
the further area of town walk &
Dublin hertlin of Ireland. Even 2
to you in Dublin. If their first information
which we get of their fate was the
announcement they had been
shot in cold blood. Personally
I defend their actions with heroism
and I believe that it has entrapped
the conscience of the country. Then the deporting by hundreds
and then murdered by their
fellows, without trial of any kind
seems to me an abuse of power,
as fatuous as it is arbitrary, and
altogether your regime has
been one of the worst and
blackened chapters in the keeping
of the government of this country I have thehappily who
Mrs w.
SirGeneral
Sir G.G. Maxwell
Commander, Dublin 3 if active in that parish it was not inside
my province that circumstances
the events of the past few locally would
make it impossible for me to have
any part in proceedings which
as wantonly cruel and oppressive. In December the government
said, when a number of British
mercenaries invaded a friendly
state and fought the republican
lawful government If each case
deserved the supreme punishment
it was they. But officially and
unofficially then if influence of the
British Government was
them, and it succeeded. You took care that plea of
mercy interpose no unlikely
often young like a
surrendered.
This letter was written by Bishop Edward Thomas O'Dwyer to Sir General John Grenfell Maxwell. This letter refers to Maxwell’s request that O’Dwyer remove two priests in his diocese so that they cannot interact with the general population. The priests concerned are Fr Thomas Wall (1877 – 1956), and Fr Michael Hayes (1873 – 1934). Maxwell reportedly called for the pair’s removal because they were providing moral support to the rebels of Easter Week 1916. According to the letter O’Dwyer, cannot see any justification for the priest’s removal. Defending the two men, O'Dwyer describes them as 'excellent priests who hold strong national views' before going on to describe Maxwell as a 'military dictator'. In a strong attack on Maxwell's handling of the rebellion, O'Dwyer states, in relation to the first exectuions, that the 'first information which we got of their fate was the announcement that they had been shot in cold blood'. In 1916 O'Dwyer (1842-1917) was serving as the Bishop of Limerick. He took up the position in 1888 and retained it until his death in 1917. Maxwell (1859 – 1929) was stationed in Ireland as he had been appointed commander in chief of the British forces in Ireland after the outbreak of the Easter Rising.
How to cite
Letters 1916, published by the Austrian Centre for Digital Humanities, Vienna, 2026 (https://letters1916static.github.io/letters1916-static/item__2690.html)
- Mentioned in
-
- Letter from General John Grenfell Maxwell to Bishop Edward Thomas O'Dwyer, 6 May 1916
- Letter from James O'Shea to John Grenfell Maxwell, 9 May 1916
- Letter from General Sir John Grenfell Maxwell to Bishop Edward Thomas O'Dwyer, 12 May 1916
- Letter from Lord French to Sir John Maxwell, 3 May 1916
- Letter from Lord Wimborne to Sir John Maxwell, 1 May 1916.
- Letter from Lord Wimborne to Sir John Maxwell, 1 May 1916
- Letter from Robert John Lynn to Sir John Maxwell, 2 May 1916
- Letter from Lord Wimborne to Sir John Maxwell, 3 May 1916
- Letter from Sir John Maxwell to Lord French, 4 May, 1916
- Letter from John Dillon to Sir John Maxwell, 8 May 1916.
- Letter from Sir John Maxwell to Herbert Henry Asquith, 12 May 1916.
- Letter from Lord French to Sir John Maxwell, 19 May 1916
- Letter from Sir John Maxwell to Lord French, 16 May 1916
- Letter from Bishop Edward Thomas O'Dwyer to General John Grenfell Maxwell, 17 May 1916
- Letter from Lord French to Sir John Maxwell, 29 April 1916
- Letter from Lord French to Sir John Maxwell, 1 May 1916
- Letter from Lord Wimborne to Sir John Maxwell, 29 April 1916
- Mentioned in
-
- Letter from Michael O'Riordan to Bishop E. T. O'Dwyer, 12 May 1916
- Letter from Eoin McNeill to Bishop E. T. O'Dwyer, 18 April 1916
- Letter from C. Moran to Bishop E. T. O'Dwyer, 15 August 1916
- Letter from W. H. Grattan Flood to Bishop E. T. O'Dwyer, 15 September 1916
- Letter from R. Barry O'Brien to Bishop Edward Thomas O'Dwyer, 12 February 1916
- Letter from General John Grenfell Maxwell to Bishop Edward Thomas O'Dwyer, 6 May 1916
- Letter from General Sir John Grenfell Maxwell to Bishop Edward Thomas O'Dwyer, 12 May 1916
- Letter from Arthur to Bishop E. T. O'Dwyer, 14 January 1916
- Letter from Fr. C. F. Maher to Bishop E. T. O'Dwyer, 16 April 1916
- Letter from Fr. Peter C. Yorke to Bishop E. T. O'Dwyer, 26 June 1916
- Letter from Michael O'Riordan to Bishop E. T. O'Dwyer, 27 May 1916
- Letter from Michael O'Riordan to Bishop E. T. O'Dwyer, 10 June 1916
- Letter from Michael O'Riordan to Bishop E. T. O'Dwyer, 23 October 1916
- Letter from M. M. Carroll to Bishop E. T. O'Dwyer, 1 June 1916
- Letter from the Limerick City Regiment of the Irish Volunteers to Bishop E. T. O'Dwyer, 14 September 1916
- Letter from Bishop Edward Thomas O'Dwyer to General John Grenfell Maxwell, 17 May 1916
- Letter from Patrick Carey to Edward O'Dwyer, D.D., 29 November 1915
- Place
- Ashford, Charleville, County Cork, Ireland
- Mentioned in
- Letter from Bishop Edward Thomas O'Dwyer to General John Grenfell Maxwell, 17 May 1916
- Place
- Irish Command Headquarters, Parkgate, Dublin, Ireland
- Mentioned in
- Letter from Colonel F. M. Taylor to Alderman Thomas Kelly, 13 June 1916
- Letter from Captain T. C. R. Moore to Alderman Thomas Kelly, 15 July 1916
- Letter from General John Grenfell Maxwell to Bishop Edward Thomas O'Dwyer, 6 May 1916
- Letter from James O'Shea to John Grenfell Maxwell, 9 May 1916
- Letter from General Sir John Grenfell Maxwell to Bishop Edward Thomas O'Dwyer, 12 May 1916
- Letter from Bishop Edward Thomas O'Dwyer to General John Grenfell Maxwell, 17 May 1916